🔗 Share this article

In a major decision, India's telecommunications ministry has confidentially directed smartphone companies to include all new phones with a state-owned cybersecurity tool that cannot be deleted. This mandate, which has been disclosed, is likely to concern major technology companies like Apple and raise questions among privacy advocates.

A Worldwide Pattern in Digital Security Policy

To combat a recent surge of digital scams and phone theft, India is joining authorities worldwide. This move echoes comparable measures framed in countries like Russia, which seek to block the use of stolen phones for scams and encourage government-developed tools.

Which Companies Are Impacted by the Directive?

The recent mandate affects leading smartphone makers operating in the domestic market. Among them are Apple, a company that has in the past had disagreements with the telecom authority over comparable applications, as well as leaders like Samsung, Vivo, Oppo, and Xiaomi.

Specifics of the Official Mandate

An order dated 28 November provides phone companies a 90-day deadline to guarantee that the official "Messenger Friend" application is factory-loaded on all new devices. A critical provision is that owners are prevented from deleting the software.

For handsets already in the distribution network, manufacturers are instructed to send the app via system updates. It is notable that this directive was sent confidentially and was communicated in confidence to specific manufacturers.

User Consent Apprehensions Expressed

However, technology experts have raised serious worries regarding this move. A legal expert specialising in technology law commented that India's action is a reason to worry.

“The government in essence eliminates user consent as a meaningful choice,” commented Mishi Choudhary, an advocate working on internet advocacy issues.

Privacy advocates had earlier questioned a similar requirement by Russia in August for a government-sponsored messenger called Max to be pre-installed on phones.

The Scope of the Domestic Market

India, one of the world's biggest telephone markets, boasts over 1.2 billion subscribers. Government figures indicate that the cybersecurity application, launched in January, has reportedly helped locating more than 700,000 lost phones, with around 50,000 found in October alone.

The government argues that the app is essential to combat the “significant endangerment” of mobile network cybersecurity from cloned or tampered IMEI numbers, which are used for illicit activities and system abuse.

Apple's Likely Response

Apple's iOS runs on an approximate 4.5% of the 735 million smartphones in India, with the rest using Android, according to industry analysis. While Apple pre-installs its own proprietary applications on its devices, its internal rules are said to prohibit the installation of any government application before the purchase of a smartphone.

“Apple has historically refused these kinds of demands from authorities,” noted Tarun Pathak, a research director at Counterpoint.

“It’s likely to aim for a compromise: rather than a forced pre-install, they might discuss and propose an option to prompt users towards installing the application.”

Requests for response from Apple, Google, Samsung, and Xiaomi were unanswered. India’s telecoms department also remained silent.

The Role of the IMEI and the Application's Purpose

The IMEI, or International Mobile Equipment Identity, is a 14- to 17-digit number unique to each mobile device. It is primarily used by carriers to block network access for phones reported as lost.

The government app is chiefly intended to enable users track and locate missing phones across all telecom networks, using a central database. It also enables them to spot, and disconnect, unauthorised mobile connections.

Impressive Usage and Outcomes

With over 5 million downloads since its launch, the software has reportedly been used to block over 3.7 million stolen or lost mobile phones. Moreover, over 30 million illegal connections have also been blocked through its use.

The government claims that the tool aids in preventing cyberthreats and helps in the locating and blocking of missing phones, thereby helping police in recovering devices and preventing cloned devices out of the black market.